And You Consider Yourself A Baseball Fan?
Diehard Pittsburg Pirates fans claim Deacon Phillippe as their own, but he’s hardly remembered in his home state of South Dakota. One of our East Coast readers, Steve Olsen, brought him to my attention this week. Deacon's story is fascinating. Clearly he should be ranked among South Dakota's greatest athletes.
He was born in Minnesota but he moved with his family to Athol, a little town in Spink County (south of Aberdeen) at age 3 and it's there he learned baseball. As a kid, he was a good hitter and a superb pitcher. He played on the town teams in northeast South Dakota. By 1896, he headed back into Minnesota to play semi-pro ball for Mankato. He drifted around the minor leagues for several years, then got his chance in 1898 when he was drafted by Louisville. On May 29, 1899 he pitched a no-hitter against the Giants in only his seventh major league game. He was among the Louisville stars who moved to Pittsburgh in 1900.
A six-footer, he was described as a "handsome man with a sturdy, oval face, a lantern jaw, dark hair parted a shade left of center." His friends called him Charlie but he got the "Deacon" nickname due to his humility and easy demeanor.
The Pirates had a great pitching staff, and he was regarded as the best.
He beat Cy Young in the very first World Series game, winning 7-3 in 1903. He pitched five games in that historic series and won three.
In all, he pitched for 13 years in the majors and had a solid win-loss record and outstanding ERA, even in his later years. He holds the MLB record today for walks per nine innings (1.25). Think of it. The kid from Athol has a record that has stood for a century, despite the likes of Sandy Koufax, Nolan Ryan, Walter Johnson, Lefty Grove and Walter Johnson.
He was modest and quiet, but outspoken enough to diss Babe Ruth. He called Babe the biggest drawback to baseball the game has ever known. "Teams quit playing smart baseball and went in for slugging," he explained in the 1940s. "I think that's what's wrong with baseball today. Everybody is aiming for the fences."
I know how he feels. Here in South Dakota we appreciate finesse.