By Bernie Hunhoff
Our native son Tom Brokaw suggested to the
New York Times this week that the Dakotas have too many colleges and universities for our sparse population. He even offered a solution: joining the two states into a Dakota Territory Public University System with satellite offices and a single administration. Here's an excerpt:
In my native Great Plains, North and South Dakota have a combined population of just under 1.5 million people, and in each state the rural areas are being depopulated at a rapid rate. Yet between them the two Dakotas support 17 colleges and universities. They are a carry-over from the early 20th century when travel was more difficult and farm families wanted their children close by during harvest season.
I know this is heresy, but couldn’t the two states get a bigger bang for their higher education buck if they consolidated their smaller institutions into, say, the Dakota Territory College System, with satellite campuses but a common administration and shared standards?
Speaking of an education, he would get one if he'd come home and run for governor in 2010 with that as his political platform.
I did some brief online research, however, and found that the broadcaster might want to start in neighboring Minnesota with his consolidation efforts. The Gopher State of 5 million people has 54 public campuses in 47 towns and cities — far more per capita than South Dakota. The University of Minnesota alone has more students than our entire system. Plus the Twin Cities have more than two dozen private schools.
I'm not necessarily picking on Minnesota. It just happened to be nearby. Let's take New York State, population 19 million and home to Brokaw and the
New York Times. I quickly counted 136 colleges — one for every 139,000 citizens. And of course they often have far bigger and more populated campuses.
We could certainly find some efficiencies in our regental system (and the legislature forced some this session with a surprise-surprise budget cut on the last day of session). But other states are greatly expanding access to higher education with free tuition, generous scholarship programs and other investments. Kentucky wants to double its number of college grads over the next few years, following the lead of other states who see higher education as the best economic development program of the 21st century.
Cutting the emphasis on higher education in 2010 might be an unintentional way of ensuring that the "greatest generation" Brokaw applauds in his books will remain the greatest generation ever in America. Along with their war experience, education made possible through the GI bill is often credited with helping our grandfathers create one of the most amazing economic boom cycles in world history.
I never thought we had too many college towns in South Dakota. Maybe we would be smarter to try to even grow and improve them? Or would that make us too much like the neighborhoods in New York State where Brokaw lives?