Share |

Leadership South Dakota

May 28, 2014

Back in March, I noticed a new program called Leadership South Dakota. The program is designed "to attract engaged citizens from across the state, then provide them with the background, unique experiences and insights necessary to assume leadership positions at the community, state and national levels."

That language said to me, "Aha! Establishment reinforcing the establishment!" So did the roster of organizers and sponsors. Staffing Leadership South Dakota are education establishment pals Rick Melmer and Tom Oster. Sponsoring the program are the usual characters: Sanford Health, First Premier Bank, Daktronics, Lawrence & Schiller and the Ramkota. With such an assemblage of South Dakota's conservative corporate cronies, how could Leadership South Dakota be anything but one more way to indoctrinate the next generation of South Dakota aspirers into the good-old-boys' club?

Then good old boy Rick Melmer himself gave me a shout. He said he's been asked if Leadership South Dakota is just a pro-Republican training camp. He says no way.

To dispel such concerns, Melmer points to three of his key assistants: Jim Beddow, Joe Bartmann and Mike Knutson. Beddow ran Dakota Wesleyan University and ran against Bill Janklow 20 years ago. He, Bartmann and Knutson have worked on other non-partisan community development projects like the Rural Learning Center and Home Address. Beddow's team will coordinate the student research component of the program and help evaluate the entire program to guide its direction for future classes.

Oh, and that Tom Oster guy? He's actually a Democrat. His grandpa Henry J. Oster served as a Democratic legislator from Davison County for 20 years. Tom Oster served on the County Commission in Democratic hotbed Brown County between 1986 and 1992.

Oster tells me the goal of Leadership South Dakota is not to build better Republicans or Democrats but better leaders. Oster says that, given how hard it is to get people to run for office, he'd be happy if Leadership South Dakota produced a larger crop of candidates for school boards, city councils and state legislature. But filling ballot slots is not the program's primary purpose. Oster hopes Leadership South Dakota builds a network of leaders in many fields, from many backgrounds, who develop a broader, shared understanding of South Dakota as one big community and who can use their new knowledge and connections to do good things for South Dakota.

To further demonstrate the program is not for Republicans only, Melmer encouraged me to apply for Leadership South Dakota. Frankly, I think participating in the program would be a hoot. Check the schedule: students spend eight months hopping around the state studying agriculture, tourism, state government, American Indian issues and more. They get to converse with South Dakota's business and government leaders (though notice, not a lot of environmentalists, human rights activists, or other community organizers who might offer lessons in leadership from someplace other than the Chamber of Commerce banquet table — Rick! Tom! Fix that!).

Alas, Leadership South Dakota costs $3,000, plus travel expenses. The first $3,000 in my pocket is spoken for (as is the next $3,000, and the next...). But Melmer tells me the South Dakota Community Foundation has some cash to subsidize tuition. And they'll give that help based on need, not party affiliation.

Melmer says Leadership South Dakota still has some spots available. Apps are due this Friday, May 30, but the form is brief, just three pages, no long essays.

Done right, Leadership South Dakota promises a platform for useful conversations. Conscientious students dedicated to a better South Dakota can help ensure it's done right. If you're interested, give Melmer and Oster a shout.

Editor's Note: Cory Heidelberger is our political columnist from the left. For a conservative perspective on politics, please look for columns by Dr. Ken Blanchard on this site.

Cory Allen Heidelberger writes the Madville Times political blog. He grew up on the shores of Lake Herman. He studied math and history at SDSU and information systems at DSU, and has taught math, English, speech, and French at high schools East and West River.


01:08 pm - Thu, May 29 2014
dave tunge said:
"to attract engaged citizens from across the state, then provide them with the background, unique experiences and insights necessary to assume leadership positions at the community, state and national levels."

While the intent may be admirable I'm quite sure one cannot "teach" leadership qualities in 8 months. If I could ramble a bit here.....on one of my pet peeves that involves leadership vs. representation. Whether city, state, or national I have witnessed over the years the evolution of leadership to its current state of representation.
One only has to look back to the 70's, even early 80's, to see the difference.
Look at the names shown on public building plaques........the folks who sat on the boards who made things happen. You saw business leaders, bank presidents, corporate CEO's, and self-employed individuals who had leadership
qualities and experience. Those folks, for the most part, are gone from todays public service. I don't think they want the hassle or exposure of today's environment. We need to get them back. I think it's critical.
Anybody can be a representative if a) you're likable or b) you have enough money. Leadership requires skill, dedication, and knowing how to make things happen............$3,000 isn't going to buy that.
03:50 pm - Thu, May 29 2014
Dave, that's an interesting debate in many fields: can we teach the skills we seek, or do the best in those fields simply develop those skills through practice? How did Bill Janklow, Dick Kneip, Joe Foss, and Peter Norbeck learn their leadership skills?

That said, while Leadership is in the title, the program seems to be less a workshop in how to lead and more a survey of major South Dakota issues... with a really good helping of networking. Did Kneip and Janklow need a class like that to govern well? Evidently not. Would they have governed better if they had had such a class?

01:24 pm - Fri, May 30 2014
Roger Holtzmann said:
David Halberstam chronicled the decline of America’s automobile industry in his book, “The Reckoning.” In it he related an anecdote about ‘Engine’ Charlie Wilson, an accomplished electrical engineer who rose in the corporate world to become CEO of General Motors, and served as Secretary of Defense from 1953-57. Pres. Dwight Eisenhower, who appointed him to the post, later remarked that if you didn’t know who Wilson was, and tried to have a conversation with him about anything other than engineering or manufacturing automobiles, you would quickly conclude he was a stupid man.

Wilson obviously wasn’t unintelligent. Eisenhower’s point, rather, was that Wilson knew very little outside his chosen field; his focus and experience was extremely narrow. Halberstam used the anecdote to make the point that Wilson’s insularity, and by extension that of the entire U.S. auto industry, was a contributing factor in its decline. They didn’t see that the marketplace was changing, and Japan was rising, until it was too late.
Halberstam’s point applies beyond the business world, and in South Dakota. It is easy to forget that, even in a small state like ours, we often don’t truly know much about our neighbors — the most extreme case being those who live on reservations. Pine Ridge might as well be in Africa for all many of us know about daily life there.
I commend the organizers of Leadership South Dakota for trying to broaden our current and future leaders’ horizons; we can quibble about the program’s finer points, but we should applaud the effort. You can’t teach or buy leadership, as Dave says. If a person has inborn leadership qualities, however, a program that increases their knowledge and exposure will make them better; if they don’t have the temperament to be leaders, it will still be a worthwhile endeavor for it makes them better citizens, and we can always use more of them.
03:43 pm - Fri, May 30 2014
That's a good point, Roger. This program tackles cultural insularity. Done right, it should also tackle political insularity.
07:46 am - Sat, May 31 2014
Robert X said:
A much better column from this author.

I too encourage the author to participate.
07:15 am - Sun, June 1 2014
("Robert", if you mean it, why not send me a check for the tuition, with your real signature at the bottom?)
02:03 pm - Wed, June 4 2014
Robert X said:

To whom should the check be written: "Cory Heildelberger" or your given name?

How long do you intend to take every criticism as a personal insult?

"Leadership" require an open mind; I'm not sure you're ready for that.

But, there's always hope.

Share your thoughts, post a comment to this story:

Your Name:
Your Email Address:  
Your Website:
2000 characters remaining
Web Design by LVSYS