Share |

Meat or Vegetables?

Apr 12, 2012

This picture has been floating around our magazine office for years. It shows early-day Watertown area hunters with their bounty from a 35-minute hunt. I like the photo because it illustrates the outdoor heritage that we all love. But it hardly speaks to sustainability. Fortunately, we've established some common sense limits on hunting and fishing in the decades since and sportsmen now fully support those limits and restrictions.

Dakota Dunes meat-packer BPI became embroiled in a national debate over food labeling this month. Five or six governors rushed to defend the beef product, along with national agriculture leaders. But even as the governors were chomping on burgers at the press conference, they and everybody watching must have been wondering where this is likely to lead.

Americans once were a lot closer to their food and their food processors. Most of us grew up in families that either butchered on the farm or bought beef, pork and poultry from a little grocery store with a butcher in the back.

But food production and processing has been consolidated, and we might actually need to start educating children on where milk and eggs and hot dogs come from. There's a bill in the Nebraska legislature this year to mandate such schooling.

Meanwhile, more and more people are becoming vegetarians or variations thereof. I was having lunch with a few young people from Sioux Falls last week when one gentleman explained that he was no longer eating meat. So he ordered a salad special. It came, to his surprise, with grilled chicken. He did a double-take, and then decided he could eat it. He's only been a vegetarian for a week, so what the heck.

He represents American. Conflicted. Curious. Rooted in a nation rich in farm, fishing and filet mignon. But thinking that some changes lie ahead.

He's re-thinking what he eats, along with many of his generation. It would be a monumental mistake for our farm state to ignore the issue and pretend that everyone will still want to eat hamburgers and hot dogs in 2050. Or that they'll faithfully eat whatever the food processors churn out.

Anyone interested in having this converstaion may want to hear Dr. James McWilliams, associate professor of history at Texas State University and author of the award-winning book Just Food: Where Locavores Get It Wrong and How We Can Truly Eat Responsibly. He will speak on “Animals, Plants and Food: Eating Sustainably in the Twenty-First Century (and Beyond)” at 7 p.m. on Saturday, April 14, in Augustana's Gilbert Science Center Auditorium, room 100. The event is free and open to the public.

According to an Augustana College media release, McWilliams’ talk will explore the idea that the primary problem with “sustainable agriculture” and “the food movement” is our failure to come to terms with the economic, environmental and ethical dimensions of animal production and consumption. The only way food can be sustainable in a world of more than 7 billion people, he argues, is to do something as radical as it is common-sensical: Grow plants for people.
“One of the things sorely lacking in our public discourse is the ability to weigh the pros and cons of an issue,” McWilliams says. “Instead, arguments about anything take on a kind of religious fervor. So when I see conventional wisdom forming around an idea, I like to poke holes in it. I think any idea with legitimacy is going to withstand having holes poked in it and will actually be stronger as a result.”

Farmers know better than anyone that change is the only sure thing. Food and eating habits are going to change dramatically in a generation or two — for a variety of reasons — and nothing will change that.


03:19 pm - Thu, April 12 2012
dave tunge said:
Is there an ethical dimension of animal production? Would that not pertain to plants also, to someone's thinking? If we can "grow plants for people" can't we also eat those plants after they have been turned into a nice rib-eye?
Granted, some changes will occur but I'm basically eating what my Grandpa did a generation or two ago..........and lovin' it.
03:53 pm - Thu, April 12 2012
Bernie said:
Dave, I'm not suggesting that it's either/or, but those of us in farming country probably should recognize the changes that are occurring, both in personal tastes and in ecological necessities.
05:11 am - Fri, April 13 2012
Lee Schoenbeck said:
We should all appreciate that across the globe, we're all sharing the same gravity and a lot of the same air and water, but there are differences. I had a lady tell me that we needed to be like a European country she has lived in, where they had bicycles that you could take and ride as you needed. She was preaching the glorious green perspective those people had. I told her it was hard to get from Watertown to Sioux Falls in the winter on a bike - borrowed or otherwise.
While cattle may not work in Africa for creating the sustainable food they need, I think we'll be ok up here on the Coteau for a few hundred more years.
05:52 am - Fri, April 13 2012
Ed Goss said:
I don't see many folks in future years in the western states eating buffalo grass, blue stem or western wheatgrass. Dandelions, maybe.
07:21 am - Fri, April 13 2012
Rebecca said:
Great post, Bernie. After I saw the documentary "Food Inc." I tried to only eat local or mostly organic meat because I felt better about how the animals were raised. But it's difficult at restaurants - as your dining companion's experience showed. And it's a slippery slope. I would compromise here and there until my eating habits were basically back to where I started. In December I went vegetarian and in February mostly vegan. I feel great physically and don't have the moral struggles I had. And I actually still support people who want to hunt because I feel like it is more humane than factory farming.
07:41 pm - Fri, April 13 2012
Jim said:
The plains we live on evolved a plant community ideal for grazing. Livestock provides great protein production, low input cost and environmental preservation, just a real sustainable system. What we see today is the removal of every possible acre of wetlands, trees and pasture to expand a vast monoculture of genetically modified and chemically supported corn. Declining demand for red meat and an apparently insatiable need for fructose and ethanol will likely continue this trend for some time. That's not a vegan /carnivore thing, just current economic reality. Unfortunately I believe we are creating a very unnatural situation that may not have long term viability.

Oh... and great picture. It really shows how things have changed over time. I will read any post with a vintage hunting photo.
07:54 am - Tue, June 30 2015
Myself and my wife like travelling. We prefer travelling on our own rather than going through the organized tours. We like meeting people in different countries and understand their cultures. Exploring the place on our own, gives different pleasure of travelling.
08:12 am - Thu, March 17 2016
The next time I read a blog, I hope that it doesn’t disappoint me as much as this one. I mean, I know it was my choice to read, but I actually thought you would have something interesting to say.

Share your thoughts, post a comment to this story:

Your Name:
Your Email Address:  
Your Website:
2000 characters remaining
Web Design by Buildable